Broken
Toys
Random comments about
games and tractors
As The RMT Turns
It must be a fairly good month for MMO patches, because all the dramabombs lately are about external sites; most of them this past week centered around Affinity’s purchase of Wowhead.
Razorwire posted a couple of days an internal Affinity email that made the rounds of blog samizdat: namely, Brock Pierce resigning as Affinity’s CEO. For those of you without RMT Insider trading cards, Pierce was IGE’s founder, and longtime partner with Jonathan Yantis, who is rumored to currently own IGE. Again. Given Pierce’s apparent fatigue from competing with Chinese gold farming outlets, it’s possible he just simply wanted to retire on his movie star/virtual gold selling millions. Thousands. Whatever.
With the purchase of Wowhead, Affinity’s VP/spokesperson John Maffei has been making the rounds insisting that with IGE’s jettisoning, Affinity and its holdings are 100% above board, uh huh, don’t throw us in with those gold farming scoundrels, we’re just like you gamers. Specifically, when asked about Affinity’s controlling interest in Korean RMT auction sites:
There’s a big focus on content– obviously, the US content business we’re very excited about, I think we’ve made a bunch of statements about that. We have an auction division, with Korea being really the foothold for that. And formerly, we used to have this division called IGE, which we no longer have.
Or, as the Affinity internal email says:
Consumer Auctions and Asset Exchange
Under Paul Kim and his team’s direction, I expect us to become serious players here in the U.S. The team has a mission to not only offer a great service but also to make game publishers into our trusted and valued partners.
This phrase was latched onto by Warcry’s J. R. “Razor” Sutich with the triumphancy of a man who had cracked the DaVinci Code.
Consumer Auctions and Asset Exchange. Hmmm… Sounds like RMT to me. Itemmania. The RMT Strikes Back. I’m pretty certain at this point that if the IGE sale was actually completed , Affinity Media is still up to their eyeballs in secondary markets.
Yet, reading Maffei’s interviews carefully (having experience in Kremlinology helps) reveals the public espousal of their private interests:
And there are legacy things involved in the company in previous times, but we are not involved in any sort of material way in the United States in the C-to-C auction business. However, I will say this. I think if the opportunity arises, where publishers are willing to go and we have the option to go work with publishers– and again, we’re not involved in this division, so I don’t own the business, so I can’t say this 100% for sure, but I think there is an opportunity, absolutely, where I think that there are some publishers who– especially those guys who make free-to-play games– who see a benefit of having a marketplace where consumers can go and exchange assets.
Don’t twist our arms, guys! Of course, Maffei is well aware of (and in facts mentions immediately Sony’s Station Exchange, which is basically proof that if a company can manage the client/server technology behind an MMO, it’s safe to say they can probably throw up an auction site as well. In other words, Maffei and Affinity’s stated goal, as clarified after the WowInsider interview was posted:
Affinity Media as a company is thinking about how we offer US publishers services for those who want to facilitate a secondary market (like Sony has) via a C2C exchange.
So, the translation: They’re not in RMT, but you know, if any company’s feeling kinda rushed or lazy, they’ll put together an auction site for them and take 6% off the top. Or maybe they’ll just do it anyway. Meanwhile, the immediate impact of the Affinity/Wowhead acquisition: lots of flash banner ads on Wowhead. Monetize, monetize, monetize!
| Print article |
about 3 years ago
Hmmmm, or have it so that the only places in the world that are any good for gaining things that are useful for high level players are PvP and let player lynch mobs deal with the gold farmers
about 3 years ago
Only way this could get more obvious.
If that supposedly ex-IGE wonk that SOE hired turns out to still be working for IGE, on loan or on contract to manage Exchange.
about 3 years ago
Effectively, nothing’s changed, Affinity, Zam and company are all knee deep in RMT and will continue to be.
about 3 years ago
“Effectively, nothing’s changed, Affinity, Zam and company are all knee deep in RMT and will continue to be.”
And people will continue to use their services…
about 3 years ago
“And people will continue to use their services…”
Which still doesn’t make it good for a game, as it does harm to the games economy, and even influences game play in other ways to curtail it’s effects, which in turn makes the game less playable for other players. “Please” indeed!
about 3 years ago
Artheos, the fact they’re talking about working with companies…suggests at the very least they’ve got a new policy direction, no? “RMT” is not a byword for evil or anything. Lots of MMO’s have RMT built-in.
about 3 years ago
Andrew,
I don’t think there was a implication of RMT being ‘evil’ in my observation.
However, since you asked… I don’t think RMT is enjoyable for me personally, and I would never participate in a game that had it – for enjoyment, because if I’m going to compete on a financial level, it’s going to be to increase my fiscal capabilities in the real world.
about 3 years ago
“Which still doesn’t make it good for a game, as it does harm to the games economy, and even influences game play in other ways to curtail it’s effects, which in turn makes the game less playable for other players. “Please” indeed!”
Thank you for finding in my one line statement what I didn’t say at all: that RMT does no harm to MMOGs. Indeed, PLEASE!
about 3 years ago
I agree, Please. I did “indeed” jump to a conclusion there. I realised it after I posted. This is probably the most common mistake that causes more flame wars on any kind of forum, not that we’re going to get into a flame war here.
But it’s hard to say….sor….sorr…..ahh, hell, I regret it, ok?
Still, it’s good to get that point out.
about 3 years ago
Semi-apology accepted.
Now, can I interest you in some gold coins? They’re China-Fresh!
about 3 years ago
I don’t play for the mmoney.
about 3 years ago
And I don’t play at all, so we’re even.
about 3 years ago
Artheos. I’m guessing you mean approved RMT there.
Personally, I don’t see why you can’t have fun AND make cash. But hey..